... and not sound like a befuddled dinosaur windbag. He knows what people like to read and comment on: it's got 225 comment so far
I wonder just when Joel went from "elitist, know-it-all blowhard" to "befuddled dinosaur windbag" -- growing old sucks.
I wasn't trying to put down Hartlaub too much, but I have issues writing articles just because he knows people will get riled up and make lots of comments. Say what you will about Selvin, but he wasn't one to pander to his audience.
But again, this is pop culture reporting, and it really is okay. Just not up to this befuddled dinosaur's standards.
yes, Peter does shoot from the hip more than Joel. Peter is def younger and I think his writing reflects that a lot. He seems more fun than Joel, although I've never hung out w Joel, so who knows? What's weird is that Joel was the "Senior Pop Music Critic" when he left the Chronicle, but I think -- to him -- pop music stopped in the mid-70s.
Joel taught Rock 1 and 2 at SF State -- I took both classes (eta: circa 1979, 80). And you are pretty much correct about his conception of popular music, though to him I don't think it even made into the '70s, period.
The classes were a blast, however, and you could tell the man truly loved his music. Lecturing, he was somewhat annoying and in your face, but when he put a record on, he transformed into just another fan.