Bringing this over from this morning's 10at10 thread: What are some of the worst Oscar noms ever? I said Ghost, but Mike said he had several less deserving films in mind, and what with the 80th awards show only days away...
To be fair I can only go back about as long as I've been alive, so the first one I can point out is Cleopatra, in 1963, which may have seen the weakest slate of nominees ever, none are anywheres near the AFI top 100 for instance.
1974, that great year for Top 40 cheese, also saw a pure cheese movie - Towering Inferno - get nommed ahead of Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore, Harry & Tonto, Murder on the Orient Express, and the Mel Brooks twin spin of Blazing Saddles & Young Frankenstein.
The Big Chill was almost as sappy as Ghost, but it didn't really steal the nom from any much more deserving film, unless you feel strongly about Silkwood or maybe Fanny & Alexander (which, although widely regarded as superior, had no chance with the academy since it's not in American, I mean English).
On the other hand it's hard to argue that Fatal Attraction deserved a nom over Empire of the Sun (at the time perceived to be a big snub of Spielberg), or even Full Metal Jacket or Matewan...in retrospect.
Likewise Babe ahead of Dead Man Walking, Leaving Las Vegas or The Usual Suspects. Or even personal fave 12 Monkeys.
So I'll probably have to conclude that Towering Inferno was the worst, and Ghost ties with Fatal Attraction for 2nd worst.