10at10 Club

Main Discussion Area => Rate-A-Record => Topic started by: urth on April 26, 2009, 09:50:39 PM

Title: The Water Song--Hot Tuna
Post by: urth on April 26, 2009, 09:50:39 PM
Now that people have weighed in on Tim Curry, let's see if Hot Tuna does any better.
Title: Re: The Water Song--Hot Tuna
Post by: mshray on April 27, 2009, 09:52:36 AM
Now that people have weighed in on Tim Curry, let's see if Hot Tuna does any better.

soemhow, for this exercise, I think in terms of calling in my vote to Dave, which I would only do once per set...versus giving as many as 10 BOS votes on the board while listening. 

The result is that, while I can easily imagine some songs that would beat out Hot Tuna in a 1972 set, I can scarcely imagine a song I'd rather vote for in a 1979 set than Tim Curry.
Title: Re: The Water Song--Hot Tuna
Post by: Gazoo on April 27, 2009, 09:16:26 PM
Now that people have weighed in on Tim Curry, let's see if Hot Tuna does any better.

soemhow, for this exercise, I think in terms of calling in my vote to Dave, which I would only do once per set...versus giving as many as 10 BOS votes on the board while listening. 

The result is that, while I can easily imagine some songs that would beat out Hot Tuna in a 1972 set, I can scarcely imagine a song I'd rather vote for in a 1979 set than Tim Curry.

I agree with Mark 100%, which is why I think a numerical rating would be a more effective if less poetic measure.

How easy is it to create a poll, btw?  I'm being lazy.
Title: Re: The Water Song--Hot Tuna
Post by: urth on April 27, 2009, 10:37:18 PM
How easy is it to create a poll, btw?  I'm being lazy.

See TinkaJohn's thread in the Stream of Consciousness board. Or the short answer: wicked simple.
Title: Re: The Water Song--Hot Tuna
Post by: ggould on April 27, 2009, 11:47:37 PM
How easy is it to create a poll, btw?  I'm being lazy.

See TinkaJohn's thread in the Stream of Consciousness board. Or the short answer: wicked simple.
or use this link:
http://10at10club.com/forum/index.php?action=post;board=11.0;poll
Title: Re: The Water Song--Hot Tuna
Post by: Tinka Cat on April 28, 2009, 06:59:50 AM
How easy is it to create a poll, btw?  I'm being lazy.

See TinkaJohn's thread in the Stream of Consciousness board. Or the short answer: wicked simple.

I deleted that silly thing....  but you can find a "post new poll" link (e.g. the link in Geoff's post above) on the main page of a board, where you post a new topic.